Disputes Between Founders of a Business Entity: Causes, Risks, and Effective Solutions

Disputes between founders (participants) of a business entity are among the most common and, at the same time, the most destructive types of corporate conflicts. In practice, it is precisely such disputes that often lead to paralysis of business operations, loss of control over assets, corporate blackmail, and years of litigation.

Within the Romano-Germanic legal system (characteristic of most CIS countries, Europe, and Central Asia), corporate conflicts have a clear legal framework; however, their successful resolution almost always depends not only on the law itself but also on a properly chosen strategy.

1. Concept and Legal Nature of Disputes Between Founders

A dispute between founders of a business entity is a conflict of interests between participants related to:

• exercise of corporate rights;

• management of the company;

• distribution of profits and losses;

• disposal of shares (equity interests);

• withdrawal of a participant from the company;

• control over assets and the business.

The key feature of such disputes is that they arise within a legal entity but affect both the personal property interests of the participants and the interests of the company itself.

2. Main Causes of Disputes Between Founders

2.1. Unequal Distribution of Corporate Control

One of the most common causes of conflicts is a situation where shares in the authorized capital are formally distributed equally (for example, 50/50), but actual control over the management of the company is not regulated.

In practice, this leads to:

• blocking decisions of the general meeting;

• inability to appoint or replace the director;

• suspension of business activities.

2.2. Conflict of Interests Between Participants and the Director

Particularly acute disputes arise when one of the founders simultaneously acts as:

• the company’s director;

• the person controlling financial flows;

• the sole signatory on bank accounts.

This creates fertile ground for abuse and loss of trust between partners.

2.3. Profit Distribution and Hidden Dividends

In practice, situations are often encountered where:

• profits are not distributed for years;

• one participant receives economic benefits through affiliated structures;

• company expenses are artificially inflated.

3. Effective Legal Solutions to Corporate Disputes

3.1. Litigation Strategy: Not “Who Is Right,” but “What Is the Goal”

Effective protection of a founder’s interests in court is built not around abstract justice but around a specific objective:

• restoration of control;

• exit from the business with compensation;

• blocking bad-faith actions of a partner.

The chosen goal determines:

• the subject of the claim;

• the scope of evidence;

• the choice of interim measures.

3.2. Interim Measures as a Tool of Pressure

In corporate disputes, interim measures play a critical role, including:

• prohibition of registration actions;

• prohibition on the alienation of shares;

• suspension of the director’s powers.

Properly applied interim measures often resolve the dispute even before a decision on the merits is rendered.

3.3. Mediation and Negotiations

Despite the judicial nature of corporate conflicts, in a number of cases:

• mediation allows the business to be preserved;

• negotiations lead to a buyout of the share at market value;

• parties minimize reputational and financial losses.

Conclusion

Disputes between founders of a business entity are not merely legal conflicts but complex problems at the intersection of corporate, contractual, and procedural law. Legal practice shows that the best solution is prevention, and if a dispute arises, a clear strategy based on law, economics, and tactics.

Well-structured corporate documents and timely legal assistance make it possible either to preserve the business or to exit it with minimal losses.

For effective resolution of disputes between founders and prevention of business paralysis, it is recommended to consult qualified professionals. Licensed lawyer Mamishir Allamuradov offers comprehensive support in corporate law, including the development of asset protection strategies and court representation. With successful experience in arbitration and civil proceedings and the preparation of more than 100 complex contracts, the expert will help find a legally sound way out of conflict situations.

Consultations are held in Ashgabat at the “Arkach” Business Center.

Contact information:

Tel.: (+993 63) 39-43-23

E-mail: mamishir.allamuradov@gmail.com

ORIENT